Relationships are not easy
- Our Blog
As the economy recovers and cyclical stocks begin to outperform, how should we think about the connection between equities and U.S. Treasury yields?
Recently, a rapid increase in U.S. Treasury yields has unsettled equity markets. To understand this short-term volatility, we need to look back to the fourth quarter of 2020, when sector leadership in the market shifted quite dramatically from specific product and service growth-oriented companies to those that benefit from a revival in broader economic activity: cyclical industries such as energy, industrials, metals and mining.
At the onset of the pandemic, our thesis was that, contingent on the development of a safe and effective vaccine, it would likely take 10 quarters to see U.S. economic activity return to pre-COVID levels. Over that time, we expected the market to begin looking past the pandemic. This has played out as we expected, even if the timing was earlier and the rebound even stronger than we had anticipated. Consistent with our view of the recovery, two important dynamics have pushed the market higher:
- Cyclical industries began to outperform secular growth companies. On a global scale, we’ve also seen emerging markets outperform developed markets, which is usually an indicator of investor confidence in the strength of the global economy.
- Treasury yields rose, representing a concern that broader economic activity would create the risk (though not necessarily the reality) of higher inflation. But how can we make sense of the relationship between yields and equities?
Going back to basics, the stock market’s value is estimated using:
A. Current earnings/cash flow
B. Estimates of the growth of those earnings/cash flow
C. A risk-free rate used to discount future earnings to the present-day value
D. An uncertainty discount (known as the risk premium) that represents the prospect that estimates will not unfold as expected. This is applied in addition to the risk-free rate.
If all else remains unchanged, the higher the risk-free rate and/or the uncertainty discount go, the more the stock market’s value should fall. However, all else never remains equal, and it certainly hasn’t recently. As investors became more confident in late 2020 about the rate and timing of the global economic recovery, the uncertainty discount diminished, propelling stocks higher. U.S. Treasury yields rose in response but did not keep up with the drop in uncertainty rate implied by the rally in stocks. The relationship among A, B, C and D above is simple to explain arithmetically, but as with any relationship, emotion plays a big part, at least in the short term. If you imagine an elastic band composed of 10-year yields and equity values, once you stretch the band, the relationship between one end and the other distorts, and something must snap back to restore the equilibrium in the relationship.
Consequently, yields “snapped” higher to restore an equilibrium reflecting greater confidence in recovery. The sectors and regions that will benefit most from the recovery are likely to continue to perform the best — but not evenly — over 2021, as confidence in the recovery ebbs and flows affecting short-term sentiment. Again, this is all very simple from an arithmetic point of view, but messy when investors’ emotions kick in.
As a result, there are also significant disagreements on the future path of inflation. If economic recovery is strong but supply chains remain disrupted after the COVID-19 lockdowns, there’s a risk of higher inflation. However, central banks may look past that temporary phenomenon and wait to see what structural trends emerge. This uncertainty is exacerbated by some anxiety about stock market valuations given how far markets have risen since successful vaccines were announced. If a modest sell-off occurs, it could be quite healthy because high expectations should be tampered.
I remain confident that the downside risk is mild relative to recent gains. The reality of global economic recovery in the second half of 2021 will most likely restore balance to the relationship between investor expectations and outcomes.
What about inflation?
Economists and investors often like to break down asset market returns into growth and inflation regimes. During times of uncertainty about inflation, it’s important to remember that if growth remains above trend, we expect to see constructive returns for equities. This has been true whether inflation is above or below trend. Of course, outrageously high inflation or extreme levels of deflation can be disruptive to an economy and its equity market, but we don’t believe there’s serious threat of either of those scenarios.